Chapter 3
A Child's Question
Aurora was five years old.
She was sitting in front of the broken mirror in the cathedral, staring.
In the mirror, there were two little wings. One white, fluffy like a cloud. One black, sharp like knives. They never matched. When she tried to fly, she only went in circles and fell on her butt.
Luna laughed from behind. "Again! You flew like a drunk chicken!"
"I did not!" Aurora pouted. Her grey and gold eyes were watery. "Luna, why is my other wing black?"
Luna stopped laughing.
Inside the cathedral, Caelum was sharpening his black sword, Eclipse. He heard everything, but he didn't answer. He had been dreading this question for five years.
Aurora ran to him, her small wings dragging on the floor. She grabbed his huge black wing with both hands.
"Papa! Papa, look!" She pointed at his wing, then at her own. "We match! Half! But why does everyone else have white wings? The angels in my dreams, they call me monster. They say I have a demon wing."
Caelum knelt. Even kneeling, he was still taller than her. He was the Angel of Darkness, feared by Heaven and Hell, but when his daughter looked at him like that, his cold face softened.
He touched her two wings — one white, one black — gently.
"Because you are not just angel, Aurora," he said, his voice low. "And you are not demon."
"Then what am I?"
"You are dawn."
Aurora frowned. "Dawn?"
Caelum picked her up and carried her to the highest broken window of the cathedral. Outside, Nocturne was still mostly night, but because of her birth five years ago, there was now a faint grey light on the horizon that never left. His doing? No. Hers.
"Look," he whispered. "What color is that?"
Aurora stared at the horizon.
"Not black... not white... grey?"
"Dawn is when night and day meet," Caelum said. "People are scared of night because it's dark. People can't look at day because it's too bright. But everyone loves dawn. Because it's in between. It's soft. It means the darkness is over, but the light is not too harsh."
He put his forehead against hers. His broken halo glowed grey, matching her little sideways halo.
"Your white wing is from your Mama Elise. Her light, her kindness, her golden blood. Your black wing is from me. My darkness, my strength, my curse."
"So I'm half Mama, half Papa?" she asked.
"You are all Mama, all Papa," he said. "Not half. Whole."
Aurora hugged his neck tight. "Then why do the other angels say I'm a mistake? I heard them last night. In my dreams, they said the Grey Child should not have been born."
Caelum's eyes turned cold again. Black. The sword Eclipse behind him trembled.
For five years, he had sealed her power with his feather necklace. For five years, Heaven couldn't find her. But now she was five, her power was growing. Her dreams were touching Heaven.
He held her tighter, his black wings wrapping around her completely, hiding her from the sky.
"Listen to me, Aurora Noctis," he whispered, and his voice was not a father's voice. It was the Angel of Darkness's voice — the voice that made demons kneel.
"If Heaven says you are a mistake, then Heaven is wrong. If Hell says you are a weapon, then Hell is wrong. You are my daughter. Do you understand?"
Aurora nodded, scared for a second.
"Anyone who calls you a monster," Caelum continued, his black feather necklace around her neck glowing to keep her calm, "I will rip their wings off. Even if it's an Archangel. Even if it's God Himself. I fell once for your mother. I will fall a thousand times for you."
Aurora started crying. Not because she was scared. Because she felt safe.
"Papa..." she sniffled. "Will my black wing ever turn white? So they will like me?"
Caelum wiped her tears with his thumb. His tear was black. Hers was half gold, half grey.
"No," he said honestly. "And you should never want it to. Your black wing is what will let you fly when your white wing is too tired. Your white wing is what will let you see light when your black wing only sees darkness. You need both."
He kissed her small sideways halo.
"You are perfect because you are different."
Outside, Elise was calling from the garden: "Caelum! Aurora! Lunch!"
Aurora giggled and tried to fly again — white wing flapping, black wing flapping — and for the first time, she didn't go in circles. She went straight for two seconds before falling into her father's arms.
Caelum laughed. A real laugh. The first time Luna had heard it in a hundred years.
And high above, far in Heaven, Seraphiel watched through a pool of light and frowned.
"She's learning to fly,is soldiers. "We don't have much